How to Raise Your Agency Prices (Scripts and Timing)

If you've been running your marketing agency for more than a year without raising prices, you're probably leaving money on the table. A lot of it.

Most agency owners stay quiet about pricing because they're afraid—afraid clients will leave, afraid of awkward conversations, afraid they're not "worth it." The irony is that staying cheap costs you more than raising prices ever will. You burn out your team on low-margin work, you attract price-sensitive clients who are always one cheaper competitor away from leaving, and you signal that your work isn't that valuable.

This post walks you through exactly how to raise agency prices. We'll cover when to do it, how much to increase, the email scripts that actually work, and how to handle clients who push back. Let's go.

Signs You Actually Need to Raise Your Prices

Before you send that price increase email, make sure you're not just feeling greedy. There are concrete signals that a price raise is overdue.

Your profit margins are below 35-40%. If you're in the agency business and your net profit is below 35%, you're essentially working for free relative to the risk you're taking. Most profitable agencies sit between 40-50% net margin. Pull your last 12 months of financials. Add up total revenue, subtract all costs (salaries, software, contractors, rent, everything), and divide by revenue. If that number is below 35%, you need to raise prices. Immediately. You're raising staff salaries but not client fees. This is one of the biggest leaks. Every time your team gets a well-deserved raise, your profit margin shrinks unless you're also raising what you charge clients. If you gave your team a 5-10% raise this year, your clients should be paying 5-10% more too. It's not optional—it's math. Your clients are asking for more work in the same scope. The project scope creeps, the meetings multiply, and suddenly you're doing twice the work for the same price. This is a pricing problem, not a scope problem. Your next price increase should include tighter scope definitions and a message that you're raising prices because you've proven additional value. You haven't raised prices in 2+ years. Even if your margins are healthy, inflation alone means you're getting paid less in real dollars. If your last price increase was in 2022, you've lost about 15% of your purchasing power just to inflation. A 10% raise every 2-3 years is table stakes. You're turning away work or feeling stretched thin. Paradoxically, this is often a sign you should raise prices. If you can't take on more clients, the solution isn't to do cheaper work—it's to do more profitable work with fewer clients. Raising prices filters out the low-margin chaos and leaves you room to actually deliver great results.

Key insight: If any of these four apply to you right now, stop reading and block 30 minutes this week to calculate your actual margins. You can't make a smart pricing decision without knowing your real numbers.

---

How Much to Raise Your Prices (The Numbers)

The answer most agency owners want: 10-20% for existing clients, 20-30% for new clients.

Let's unpack this.

10-20% for existing clients (annual increases). This is the sweet spot for keeping clients happy while recovering margin. A 10% increase feels material to you (it's 10 more percentage points of profit) but doesn't feel unreasonable to a client who's been with you for a year. It tracks inflation plus a small bit of premium for the relationship and results you've delivered.

If you're increasing in the middle of a contract, 10% is more defensible. If you're increasing at renewal, you can push to 15-20% if:

• You've delivered measurable results (sales, leads, traffic, whatever the metric is)
• The client has signed a new contract or expanded scope
• You're justifying it with value, not just "it's been a year"

20-30% for new clients. This is where most agencies leave money on the table. You've figured out your processes, your team is better, your work is stronger. Yet you quote the same price you quoted two years ago. Stop.

If an existing client leaves and you pick up a new one at the same service level, your new client should pay 20-30% more. You're more efficient. You have better systems. You've learned what works. That's worth something.

Go higher if you're in specific niches. If you specialize in something profitable—e-commerce conversion, SaaS paid ads, real estate marketing—you can go 25-35% higher than generalist agencies. You have less competition, more specificity, and clients in those spaces have more money to spend. Go lower if you're not profitable yet. If you're below 30% margin, your priority isn't a huge single increase; it's a systematic repricing. Maybe 5-10% now, then another 10-15% in 6 months once you've fixed your delivery process and can prove more efficiency. One big increase feels aggressive; two medium increases feel like you're getting better at your job.

---

Two Pricing Strategies: Grandfather vs. Across-the-Board

When you decide to raise prices, you have two options. Each has tradeoffs.

The Grandfather Approach (Selective Increases)

You raise prices only on contract renewal or new clients. Existing clients on active contracts keep their rate.

Pros:

• Feels less jarring to long-term clients
• You only have one price conversation per client (at renewal)
• Easier to manage—existing clients = old rate, new contracts = new rate

Cons:

• You end up with a mess of different client rates doing the same work
• Takes 2-3 years for your pricing to fully reset (if clients are on annual contracts)
• You're leaving money on the table for every month an old-rate client is still active

When to grandfather:

• You have a lot of long-term clients (8+) and big annual contracts
• You're worried about client churn and want to minimize friction
• Your margins are already solid and you can afford to wait

The Across-the-Board Increase

You raise prices for all clients, effective [date]. Existing contracts get increased rates at their next renewal point (or immediately if possible).

Pros:

• Faster margin improvement (you're not waiting for renewals)
• Cleaner—everyone paying current market rate within 3-6 months
• Signals strength and confidence in your pricing

Cons:

• More conversations, more pushback
• Higher risk of losing a few clients
• Requires a clear, well-communicated message to not feel arbitrary

When to do across-the-board:

• You have high churn or lots of short-term contracts (3-6 months)
• Your margins are bad and you can't afford to wait for renewals
• You've just raised prices on new clients and need to catch up

What we recommend: Start with grandfather if you have long-term relationships, switch to across-the-board once you're scaling. Most agencies we talk to end up doing both—grandfather their current clients, but institute a policy that all contracts increase 10% at renewal.

---

The Perfect Timing for a Price Increase

Timing matters. A lot.

Option 1: Annual contract renewal (best for existing clients).

Set a policy: "All contracts renew on [month] 1 and are subject to 10-15% annual increase." Then when renewal time comes, it's already built in. No surprise email—just a renewal proposal with the new rate. The client sees it on the renewal cycle and can factor it into their budget planning.

Action step: If you don't already have annual renewal dates, pick one this month. Make every contract renew on, say, March 1. Then next March 1, all your price increases hit at once. It simplifies your cash flow and client conversations.

Option 2: After a big win or successful campaign (psychology wins).

You just drove 200 new qualified leads for a client in Q2. Revenue is up. The client is happy. This is your moment. Send a message like: "We've been thrilled with the results we've delivered—[specific wins]. As we continue this momentum, we're adjusting our rates to [X] starting next month. Here's what's included."

The client just got proof of value. They're in a good mood. They're much less likely to push back.

Option 3: Immediately upon contract signing (cleanest for new clients).

Don't negotiate your new-client rate. If a prospect balks at your new, higher quote, you have three options: (a) they don't get services, (b) they get a stripped-down version at the new rate, or (c) they wait for your capacity. Don't drop price. You'll train them to negotiate everything.

Option 4: At the start of a new fiscal year (organization wins).

If your fiscal year starts in January or July, announce price changes then. It feels official, planned, and tied to business cycles rather than arbitrary.

When NOT to raise prices:

• In the middle of a crisis (theirs or yours)
• During contract renegotiation (unless renewal is coming anyway)
• While they're actively unhappy or have pending complaints
• In a 1-on-1 call without warning (always give advance notice via email)

---

The Price Increase Email Template (Copy and Paste)

Here's a script that works. Modify the numbers and details for your agency.

---

Subject Line: Important update: [Agency] pricing and your account

Hi [Name],

I wanted to reach out with an important update about your account with us.

Over the past [X months/year], we've delivered strong results for your team:

• [Specific metric 1]: increased from [X] to [Y]
• [Specific metric 2]: [quantified outcome]
• [Specific outcome]: [result]

Those wins are a direct result of how we've evolved our team, process, and technology. We've invested in deeper expertise, faster turnaround times, and better strategic thinking—all of which have improved the results you're seeing.

Effective [date], we're adjusting our retainer rate to [new rate] (previously [old rate]). This [X]% increase reflects the value we've proven and ensures we can keep delivering at this level.

Here's what you can expect:

• Same dedicated team leads and timeline commitments
• Quarterly strategy reviews (new)
• Direct Slack access (new)
• [One new concrete thing you're adding]

[One sentence about contract term—is it month-to-month, annual? This is key.]

I know price changes aren't fun to see. If you have questions or want to discuss how this impacts your budget, let's hop on a call this week. But I'm confident this increase is fair given what we've delivered.

Looking forward to continuing this partnership.

[Your name]

---

Why this works:

1. It leads with value (specific results), not apologies

2. It explains the "why" (better team, better results)

3. It adds something concrete (new service, new access, new frequency) so it doesn't feel like pure margin grab

4. It gives a decision timeline but isn't aggressive

5. It invites conversation without apologizing

Variations by client type:

If the client is very price-sensitive and you're nervous:

"...we're adjusting our retainer to [new rate]. We know this is a change, and we want to make sure it makes sense for your budget. Let's talk through the options—we may be able to phase this in or structure it differently."

If the client is thrilled with results and less price-sensitive:

"...we're adjusting our retainer to [new rate] to reflect the market value of what we're delivering. Given [specific result], we're confident you're getting exceptional ROI. Here's the new agreement."

If you're worried about churn:

"We're raising our rate to [X] for new clients effective immediately. For your account, the new rate takes effect at your January 1 renewal. This gives you time to budget for it, and it lets us serve you at the level you deserve."

---

How to Handle Pushback (And When to Hold Firm)

Not everyone will accept a price increase gracefully. Here's how to handle the most common objections.

Objection: "That's a huge increase. Can you negotiate?"

Response: "I understand it feels like a jump. But look at what we've delivered: [specific metric]. At the industry rate for this outcome, you'd typically pay 20-30% more. We're asking for 15%. That's a good deal."

If they push again: "I appreciate you value the partnership. But we've landed on this price based on our costs and the market rate for these results. We're not going lower. Would you like to adjust your scope instead?"

Objection: "I'll shop around. I can get this cheaper elsewhere."

Response: "Fair—always good to look. Shop around, and if you find better results at that price, that's useful data. Here's what I'd ask: compare not just price but their track record on [metric that matters to them]. We're confident our results are worth the premium."

Then stop talking. Don't over-explain or get defensive. If they come back lower, they've shopped around and chose you. That means they know you're worth it.

Objection: "Can we phase this in? Maybe 5% now, 5% later?"

Response: Only if they sign a longer contract. "We can do 5% now and 5% in six months—but that locks you in for a 12-month contract instead of month-to-month. Does that work?"

This way you're trading flexibility for longer commitment, which benefits both of you.

Objection: "We need to think about it."

Response: "Of course. New contract takes effect [date]. If you need to make changes to your scope or term to fit the budget, let me know and we can brainstorm."

Then set a deadline. "I need to know by [date] so I can finalize our Q1 planning." Don't let this drag indefinitely.

---

When to Let a Client Go Instead of Raising Prices

Here's the hard truth: not every client is worth keeping.

If a client is going to push back hard on a reasonable price increase, or if the account is barely profitable at your current rate, letting them go might be the right call. Sounds counterintuitive—but here's the math:

You have 10 clients. One of them is a pain. Constant scope creep, slow to pay, argues about everything. They're paying you $5k/month, but the account takes 80 hours of work. That's $62.50/hour. Your other clients average $150/hour. When they push back on your raise, you're faced with a real choice:

1. Keep them at the old rate (you're getting worse)

2. Raise the rate, they leave (you're freed up)

3. Cut scope dramatically and raise the rate (you get better clients or just less chaos)

Let a client go if:

• Your margin on them is below 20% (they're a loss leader)
• They consume more than 20% of your time relative to revenue (they're inefficient)
• They argue about price before you've even started (that won't improve)
• You dread working with them (this is a signal)

A script for ending a client relationship:

"After working together for [X], I think it's time we both move on. Your needs and our service model aren't aligned—you'd be better served by a larger agency that has more capacity, and we need to focus on clients where we're delivering exceptional results. I recommend [competitor]. We'll transition smoothly over [timeframe]."

That's it. No apologies, no lengthy explanation. Most agency owners spend months dreading this conversation, then it's done in an email.

---

New Client vs. Existing Client Pricing

This is a framework that solves most pricing problems: new clients pay more, existing clients get grandfathered.

New client pricing: This is your market rate. It's what you'd charge someone walking in off the street with no history. If your existing rate is $5k/month, new client rate might be $6.5k-$7k/month. You've learned, your team is better, your processes are tighter. Existing client pricing: They stay at their current rate until contract renewal. Then they move to a new-client rate (or 80-90% of it if you want some loyalty discount). Why this works:

• It rewards loyalty without leaving money on the table forever
• It incentivizes clients to stay (they know the rate goes up at renewal)
• It lets you raise prices on new business immediately without client conversations
• It makes your sales team happy—new quotes are higher, making conversion feel easier

Pro move: Make new-client pricing public (sort of). When an existing client asks "how much for a new service," quote them new-client rates. When they ask why it's more, you explain: "New services come at our current market rate. Your retainer is locked in at your renewal rate."

Most clients accept this instantly because it makes sense.

---

The Systems Approach: Making Pricing Increases Predictable

Here's the thing: if you're scrambling every two years